Milani Liquif Eye Metallic Eye Liner Pencil(s)

There's no real review here, though the swatches on my hand are not budging. I picked up Brown and Black. Both are decidedly matte (or really more of a satin as the colors are not completely flat) and not metallic like they claim but rather nice, creamy, smooth and very pigmented.

I'll write a proper review when I've tested them on both the lid and waterline.